|
navbartop.gif
|
 |
|
|
Appalachian
Splint Baskets |
|
|
|
|
|
Most of us see baskets everyday and never question
their use, origin or value. Think
about it the next time a gift arrives from the florist in a wicker or reed
basket or when you gather the laundry or a bushel of apples.
Since the dawn of time man has been weaving baskets
to store necessary items such as grain, oil and even water. The basic form
was usually dictated by the intended use and the materials used were
available locally. Accounts
of early cultures such as the Egyptians or Native Americans make reference
to the production and use of baskets.
In the Orient and in coastal areas river cane or grasses might have
been used. In America,
baskets were made in the Piedmont, Mountain or Plains regions using
materials such as wooden splints, animal hides and grasses.
For this article, I’ve decided to focus on a few of
the baskets found in the Mid Atlantic and Appalachian regions.
My first experience with basket making occurred when I met “Miss
Mary”, a Southwest Virginia lady in her 80’s.
“Miss Mary” was an artisan who made baskets for a local crafts
co-op in the 1970’s and early 80’s.
I remember her astonishment at learning that people would buy her
baskets for “show” rather than using them to bring in produce from the
garden.
In visiting Miss Mary I got a close-up education in all the work and
skills required to turn an oak tree into a basket. Miss Mary and her
nephew would go out into the forest around her home and search for white
oak saplings 4” to 6” in diameter.
After carefully selecting the tree the nephew would fell it and cut
off the bottom 8’ or so and remove the bark.
Then he would take a chisel and draw knife and pull strips off the
tree about ½” to 1” wide, which would then be worked down into thin
splints. These splints were then soaked in a creek to make them pliable so
Miss Mary could weave her magic.

Figure
1
Figure
2
Figure 2a |
|
For those of us who collect antique baskets the biggest challenge comes
when we have to decide how much “magic” is woven into our baskets or
potential purchases. The
simplest system I can think of involves thinking of the basket first as an
object of art. This means we
need to look at the eye appeal, form, finish, patina and age.
Figure 1 shows a classic gizzard or buttocks basket
in a dry surface with nice old patina.
Baskets like this were made in all sizes from one or more bushels
down to miniatures that will fit in the palm of your hand.
The one pictured is about 2” high and 3” wide. It’s so finely
woven that the photo could deceive you into thinking it was much larger.
The price for this basket could be $3,000 or more. Figure 2 is a basket similar to Figure 1 but this
form is called a melon shape because it’s flat on the bottom. The size on Figure 2 is 6” high x 7” wide and it has nice
patina. Figure 2A gives us
another nice clue – the handle and the rim are secured by a cut nail.
This means this particular basket is from the 1870’s or earlier.
It’s my opinion that over 90% of the baskets we see in today’s
market and collections were made after 1900.
Figure 3 shows another desirable form – a hanging
basket. These were made for
key storage or papers and I’ve even heard some people in the country got
their mail in them. Figure 5 shows a round basket with some unusual characteristics.
The handle is signed and dated from New Market, Virginia, April 14,
1935. When compared to the other examples this basket is not very finely
woven but its patina, date, and location make it very desirable.

Figure
3
Figure
5
Figure 11
|
|
|
Most advanced Americana and country furniture
collectors always seek baskets with great form, patina and particularly
old painted surfaces. The
most unusual basket related item I’ve ever seen is the splint bed mat
shown in Figure 11. These
mats were woven to put over the ropes in 19th and 19th
Century beds so the feather tick (mattress) wouldn’t sink down between
the ropes. As the photo shows, this item makes a great background for a
wall display. Sometimes the
biggest challenge to a basket collector comes in trying to display baskets
in an attractive fashion.
Most of us set our prized baskets on tables,
cupboards, and even the floor. The
good news is that most baskets were made to be used and are actually very
sturdy. As long as you
don’t clean them with harsh detergents they should be good for future
generations. However, I
strongly advise putting miniatures and fragile baskets in cupboards behind
glass. The basket shown in
Figure 1 is worth a lot more in its perfect state than it would be with
even one broken splint.
It’s very encouraging that a lot of nice oak splint
baskets can be bought for $250 or less.
I would estimate that the vast majority of baskets we well in our
uncatalogued auctions sell in this price range. As you increase your knowledge and look for great miniatures,
rare regional forms or painted baskets the price can get in four figures
very quickly. Good Hunting!
|
|
This
excerpt was written by Ken Farmer 2003 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ken
Farmer Winter
Estate Auction |
|
|
|
|
|
A sudden winter
snowstorm in the South could not blanket the enthusiasm for a standing
room only crowd at Ken Farmer’s on Saturday, February 8, 2003. Preceded
by a Friday night champagne and cocktail preview, Farmer welcomed gallery
regulars and out-of-town visitors to his newly expanded and renovated
facility, where new sales records were established for high end
merchandise along with Southern art.
Deaccessions from a
Southern museum of art and an historical society meant fresh and exciting
goods for dealers and collectors in the showroom, on the telephone, and
from cyberspace. Among the
featured items was a Southern walnut with yellow pine Queen Anne dressing
table ($55,000), a Goldsmith Chandlee (Virginia)
engraved surveyor’s compass ($11,212), a Wythe County, Virginia
pie safe with tulip punched tins ($3,902), and an Arts and Crafts period
oak sideboard, signed “L & JG Stickley ($3,624).
(All prices reflect a 15% buyer’s premium).
|

|
|
Among the art was a J. G.
Brown oil “The Dilettante”, showing an urchin fishing a broken vase
from the trash ($16,100); a large bright neo-Expressionist oil on canvas
by Israeli painter Menashe Kadishman ($4,600).
A colorful “Negro Dance” by Warre LeBron, cofounder of the
Dixie Art Colony, sold to New York dealer Debra Force bidding for a client
($7,188).
An extra grade Wooton
patent desk in walnut, and dated from 1884 ($21,850) and a 1985
Rolls-Royce Camargue Coupe ($37,353) rounded out the successful sale.
The Southern walnut
dressing table, turned up by Farmer and one of his associates during an
appraisal day in the Virginia mountains, proved to be an enigma to
collectors and dealers of Southern furniture, and it is hoped will open
new avenues of scholarship for the maker.
|
|
The Queen Anne one over
three drawer dressing table has an engaging pierced Rococo apron, Quaker
drawer locks, and foliate carved knees with a suppressed claw and ball
foot. Likely a back country
interpretation of cabinetmakers’ work from Williamsburg, Norfolk, or the
Chowan basin, the piece has an innate charm that only a vernacular
interpretation of high style furniture can offer.
Farmer solicited assistance from the Museum of
Early Southern Decorative Arts (MESDA), Colonial Williamsburg, and
prominent dealers, none of whom could seem to agree on the origin of the
piece. One knowledgeable
collector stated emphatically that the piece was a product of Norfolk,
while a dealer strongly attributed it to the Perquimans County, NC area,
and another placed the attribution to a journeyman cabinetmaker from the
Hay or Scott shops in Williamsburg, and perhaps produced in the Valley of
Virginia. The only
known/published origin relates it to one of the founding families of
Virginia.
Some controversy arose as
to the originality of the top, but Farmer and dealer Sumpter Priddy, III
were one hundred per cent certain of the top’s authenticity.
When the piece came onto the block, an anticipated phone bidder
dropped out, leaving the auctioneer to pass the lot, only to be
resurrected and sold where another call produced the successful bidder, a
prominent Eastern Virginia collector
.
.
|
 |
|
This
excerpt was written by Robert K. Miller |
|
|
|
|
A
buzz underneath the tent |
|
|
|
|
|
Just
a block from the
Doe
River
and the famous covered “kissing”
bridge
of
Elizabethton
,
Tennessee
, was the site of the latest
Ken Farmer
auction on April 20th. Conducted
on the premises of the former home of Samuel Powhatan Carter, a direct
descendent of Landon Carter the founder of Carter County, Tennessee, the
sale was the first quarter million dollar personal property sale for the
Farmer group of 2002. Held
under his trademark red and white striped tents, the auction and the
preview collected the largest crowd in recent county memory.
According to
Jodi Webb
, she registered 150 bidders during the preview on the day before.
By auction day, over 500 spectators crowded under the two tents of
merchandise to watch the show. With
the large crowd, local politicians running for office could be seen
threading their way through outstretched hands.
Even Lamar Alexander, who once attempted a run for the Presidential
nomination and is now running for a Senate seat in the state, was in
attendance.
Because of the
historical significance of the items to the surrounding county, prices
were expected to be strong and the crowd was wowed by some of the final
bids.
Ken Farmer
, taking it all in stride, calmly called the bids and interspersed a
crowd-pleasing joke or story, amid a flurry of bidding.
After initial announcements, Farmer started promptly at 10 with a
24” marble bust of a woman wearing a scarf.
The final price of $715 (all prices include the 10% buyers’
premium) immediately started a buzz among those seated under the tent, while those outside jostled
in closer. Next, a hand
painted, electrified Gone With the Wind style lamp brought $165, an
unusual Heisey, tri-level hors d’oeuvres stand brought $330, and an
English ironstone plateau ended at $770.
With the crowd’s appetite whetted, the first advertised star of
the auction, a
Tennessee
urn-pattern punched tin Jackson Press (c. 1820-1840), cherry with poplar
secondaries, crossed the block. With
turned feet and paneled sides, molded cornice over two doors with 24
lights, the two-piece cupboard sold for $16,500 sold to Asheville dealer
Charlton Bradsher bidding for a client.
|

|
|
Interspersed
with small items—a brass-covered English wood fireplace screen for $302,
a small wicker baby carriage with a Sun rubber baby dollar (left too long
in the heat of the attic) for $82, and an English blue and white
transferware tureen with an old staple repair over a side crack for
$385—came the other advertised stars of the show.
A rare Aesthetic Revival two-piece bow front corner cupboard, c.
1870, with burl veneers intact, Heraldic faces on cornice and finial, with
a single arched lighted door over two doors with applied cornucopia
carving sold to a local dealer for $11,000.
A more subtle two-piece Empire stepback cherry cupboard with burl
veneers and 16 lights over 2 drawers over 2 doors brought $5,500.
A pair of centennial
style chairs, made of mahogany, with ribbon carving came in the high side
of $1000 and an Empire secretary/bookcase, cherry, burl veneers, and
poplar, with cathedral windowpanes ended finally at $10,725 after one
determined bidder outbid four others who were still in as the piece went
beyond $9,000. The
Tennessee
cherry corner cupboard, c. 1800, with rope, tassel, and string inlay, and
stars and corners inlaid in the panels, went for $16,500. The price of the
corner cupboard was held down by it’s replaced cornice, and like most of
the collection, it was refinished. To
the surprise of several in the crowd, it wasn’t the corner cupboard or
the Jackson Press that was the high price item of the day.
A Regency Revival Tester Bed, of mahogany and veneers, standing
over 8 feet tall, brought serious interest from three very determined
bidders. These three, a local
collector, a family member, and a collector just outside the region who
wanted it for her personal collection, took the bed to a final price of
$20,900, and it stayed in the family.
After the sale this reported spoke with this relative who
identified himself as Mr. William Ivy Long.
Mr. Long said he was a distant relation and has come down from
New York City
to attend the auction.
By this time,
slightly over an hour into the sale, the crowd was used to the high
numbers and seemed unabashed at spending fewer dollars for smalls and
collectibles. A green glass
demi john stopped at $192; an authentic betty lamp, though covered with
grime from years in an outside shed brought $38; a small bisque doll and a
pair of larger baby leather shoes, with the soles in nearly unwalked on
condition, reached $77; boxes of pressed glass ranged from $16 to $150;
WWI and Korean War era naval uniforms went for $70 to $130; and several
pieces of Victorian clothing with black beading, ranged from $10 to $130 a
piece. A four-piece celluloid
dresser set ended at $66. A
92-piece set of Moss Rose china went for $330.
Pressed glass oil lamps averaged $22 to $38; and an unusual small
round metal mousetrap was snatched up for $11.
The Farmer auction crew did an amazing job of spotting bids, since
every lot seemed to have at least some popularity among several bidders
throughout the tent and outside, some even bidding while putting mustard
on their hot dog at the food tent. As
a local older gentleman, dressed nattily in a gray suit, remarked to me,
“I’ve been to auctions all my life and this may be the best run outfit
I’ve ever seen.”
A Victorian Rococo
Revival over the mantle mirror finished at $1430, and other mirrors, most
in pine, walnut, or cherry frames, brought $55 to $330.
A cherry drop leaf table, with boldly turned legs, reached $2200; a
walnut country wardrobe from the mid-nineteenth century ended up at $930;
an American Empire mahogany sewing stand, with three nicely defined paw
feet, went home for $1210; and a country Sheraton one-drawer stand, walnut
with a four-board top, was hammered down for $605.
Some seemed surprised that a walnut grandfather clock with a
Litchfield face and works sold for $6,600.
According to Farmer, it was quite common for
East Tennessee
clock makers to construct their cases locally and order the works and
faces from
New England
or
Germany
. The clock purchaser stated
that he paid more than he expected, but that this purchase ended his 20
year search for an
East Tennessee
tall clock. A country walnut
candlestand, with legs mortised in the post and in need of refinishing
went for $220. A walnut pump
organ, many were careful not to scratch their nose during this piece,
still went for $660 to a least one person happy to get it.
Art, too, was
popular among bidders and several oil paintings, done just before the turn
of the century, some signed by local artists, went to new homes, including
one where a woman was frantically coaxing permission to bid out of a cell
phone. An oil on canvas of
sheep parading in line down a stormy sea coast brought $220.
An OOC of girl in a boat, from the 1890s, also went for $220.
A small OOB of a dark seascape stopped at $66.
An oil of violets, not quite a yard, brought $385, and an OOC of
descendent Elizabeth Carter went for $1100.
A charcoal study of a lady, approx. 2 x 3 feet brought $88, and a
large Victorian engraving of mother and child in a plain oak frame reached
$385.
. |
|
Many
books of historical value were in the estate and brought market prices
during the auction. A volume
of Summers’ 1903 “History of Southwest Virginia,
Washington
County
,” stopped just short of $100. The
1872 12-volume set of the “Ku Klux Conspiracy—Testimony on Condition
of Affairs of Late Insurrectionary States,” brought $385.
Bancroft’s six volumes of the “History of the
United States
” from 1891 reached $66, and 10 volumes of Nicholson’s Encyclopedia
(1818) changed hands $165. 195
early 1800s books, leather bound and written in Greek and Latin, brought
$1,210.
Tennessee
and regional historical books were also popular, ranging in price from $66
to $385 per volume, the highest price for Wheeler’s “History of North
Carolina” published in 1851. The end of the day seemed to be that the
Tennessee
collectors and distant relatives were dead set on keeping their heritage
in the state. Also, in this
day when there are so many anonymous objects this sale offered buyers a
chance to buy good objects with a great provenance.
. |

|
|
This
excerpt was written by Steve Culver |
|
|
|
|
|
Oil
on canvas |
|
|
The
Misses Stewart Hodgson |
|
|
Painted
by Frederic, Lord Leighton, P.R.A. (1830-96), was recently discovered by
Ken Farmer in the collection of Mildred H. Boink. The painting was in the
possession of the Boink family for over 20 years.
The Boinks originally purchased the Leighton for $400 from the widow of a
local industrialist, who collected art in the 60s. Originally, the family
members mistakenly believed the oil to be signed by an artist named
"Bart." Soon, after extensive research and verification, the
painting was discovered to be a lost Frederic Leighton painting, once
exhibited at the Royal Academy Winter Exhibition of 1897.
The painting went on to be sold over the Internet with Sothebys.com on
Nov. 29, 2001. It became the most expensive canvas ever sold on online for
a bidding record of $550,700. Double mid estimates…
|

|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Folk
Pottery |
|
|
A
Rediscovered Masterpiece |
|
|
. |
|
|
This
remarkable object, a rare alkaline-glazed stoneware figural jug made by
John Lehman in Randolph County, Ala., circa 1870, was offered for sale by
Ken Farmer Auctions on sothebys.com last month.
John
Frederick Lehman - born about 1825 in Germany and arriving in the United
States during the 1850s - is responsible for two of the most impressive
ceramic figural vessels produced by European- American potters during the
19th century, This is one of them, the other example that is virtually
identical except for a more elaborate costume, is in the collection of the
High Museum of Art, Atlanta.
Both are impressed on both lapels J.LEHMAN within a circle and
around a star.
The
jug was discovered at the Antiques
Roadshow
in Miami last year. In
remarkable condition, with just a few chips and minor hairline cracks, it
created plenty of interest before bidding closed on Feb. 21 at $72,500
($80,500 including buyer's premium).
.
|

|
|
This
excerpt was taken from an article in the March 11, 2002 Eastern edition of
Antique Week, Vol 34. Issue 1711 |
|
|
|
. |
|
Ken Farmer holds Sotheby's affiliated auctions several times a year |
|
|
140-year-old Alabama figural jug |
|
|
|
|
|
Everyone wasn't watching the Daytona 500 on Sunday. In Radford, there was no
fried chicken, no cold beer and no Dale Earnhardt Jr. caps.
Instead, art and antique enthusiast’s sipped red wine, ate shrimp and quiche, and enjoyed what Ken Farmer calls 'the best-kept secret in Southwest Virginia."
Farmer, an appraiser and auctioneer, runs one of the few international online auction houses in the Mid-Atlantic and the only one in Western Virginia. Farmer, who holds Sotheby's-affiliated auctions several times a year, had his latest showing Sunday.
The items included a 140-year-old Alabama figural jug that sat by itself in a glass case. The minimum bid - $50,000.
Last November, Farmer sold a painting for $560,000 - an online record for such a sale. Farmer found "The Sisters Hodgson," painted by Lord Frederick Leighton, while assessing an estate in the Midwest, and his research unveiled the painting's value, which had eluded the experts from Sotheby's and Christie's.
"Even a blind squirrel finds an acorn every now and then," he said with a laugh. The estate had made a contractual agreement to take
a $ 10,000 minimum.
|


|
|
The story of the figural jug is just as rich. Its owner, James Madison University graduate Cathy Harlem, lives in Miami. She was in Radford on Sunday and she stood and stared at her jug for quite awhile. Tears welled up in her eyes. “I just came to say goodbye,” she said.
The jug has been handed down by generations of women in Harlem's family. Until Harlem decided to have the jug appraised last year, no one knew its value. Years ago, Harlem's parents threw the jug in their car as they moved from Alabama to Maryland. When Harlem's mother decided to give the pottery to her daughter last year, she and her husband wrapped it in some towels and drove to Miami, stopping many times along the way.
“It was just there in the back of the car," said Harlem's mother, Nettie O'Neal. The jug made it safely to Miami.
Harlem decided to have it appraised when the PBS television program "Antiques Roadshow” came to town. That's where she met Farmer, who is affiliated with the show.
Harlem was astonished to learn that the jug, made by a relatively obscure but highly regarded artist named John Lehman, could be worth more than $ 100,000.
She put it in a closet because she was scared that her cat, Squirt, might break it.
“I have a cat that will pee on any vertical surface,” she said.
Harlem decided she could never keep her sanity holding on to such a valuable piece of folk art. So she cut a deal with Farmer.
Farmer is confident someone will make a big bid closer to the deadline.
Sunday's auction also included other displayed items such as a George Washington letter from 1780, a lock of
his hair, and a portrait of Washington.
Farmer said, as fascinating as high-dollar auctions are, they’re not his bread and butter. He also holds auctions of furniture, guns and other antiques on the first
and third Tuesdays of the month. “I’m prideful of what I do,” said Farmer, a Pulaski native. “A lot of people think Virginia culture ends in
Richmond, but Radford is a great small town, and I enjoy living here.”
This
article was taken from the February 18, 2002 edition of The Roanoke Times
Virginia Section |
|
|
|
navbartop.gif
|
| |
|
| |
Jim
Woltz, Ken Farmer see synergies |
|
| |
Real
Estate firms form new alliance |
|
| |
|
|
| |
Whether the job is
to auction land, estates or antiques, Jim Woltz and Ken Farmer are sold
on the idea of working together.
They met 25 years
ago while playing bluegrass music. Woltz played banjo while Farmer played
guitar. Both have recorded albums and still play in their spare time.
Now, the owners of
Woltz & Associates Inc., of Roanoke, and Ken Farmer Auctions, of Radford,
plan to do business together. They will jointly market their companies
by acknowledging one another in their brochures and by providing links
to each other's Web sites.
Woltz & Associates
primarily sells large tracts of land, estates and commercial properties
while Farmer, who also sells real estate and land, specializes in antique
auctions. Farmer will help Woltz if there is a large personal property
sale and Woltz will help Farmer if his company receives a multi-parcel
sale, the companies said.
"Because of the changing
markets, regulations and an ever-expanding base of product knowledge,
all auctioneers are challenged to work within their areas of expertise
and seek partnerships with qualified firms when clients needs services
that require a different specialization," Farmer said.
Both companies have
established a name for themselves
Farmer, a licensed
real estate broker since 1985, has been a regular appraiser on PBS' "Antiques
Roadshow" since 1997. He also has appeared as a guest on the Oprah Winfrey
show to discuss antiques. His company's sales were about $2.3 million
last year.
|


www.woltz.com
|
| |
Woltz, a broker, has been selling rural, commercial and industrial lands
for more than 26 years. Woltz and Associates' 1999 sales totaled more than
$30 million. The company is licensed in Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina,
Pennsylvania, Tennessee and Colorado.
Both men know the
value of technology
Woltz & Associates
has the capacity to do live online bidding. It is the only Virginia company
with the rights to a computerized, multi-parcel bidding process, the company
said.
The online process,
implemented in April 1999, "keeps everybody in the game," said David Brammer,
auction coordinator at Woltz & Associates. "It's good for a small-tract
bidder who is bidding against a large developer."
Traditionally a stretch
of land, a tract, is divided into smaller tracts. These individual tracts
are bid on, then bids on a combination or grouping of the smaller tracts
are accepted. Once a higher bid is received on a combination of tracts,
individual bidders are unable to bid higher on their desired tract.
The online system
allows bidding to continue on a single plot of land, even after several
plots have been grouped together for sale. When the bidding ends, the
combination with the highest dollar amount is sold. Woltz said the multiparcel
process has increased sales revenue by 50 percent.
Farmer conducts his
auctions in a 12,000-square-foot auction center in Radford and online
through Sotheby's Web site. The gallery is complete with video display
of auctions in progress and 12 phone lines connecting absentee bidders
to the sales.
Woltz and Farmer are
members of the National Auctioneers Association and The Certified Auctioneers
Institute and Woltz belongs to the National Association of Realtors.
This
article was taken from the July 26, 2000 edition of The Roanoke Times
Business Section
|
|
|
| John
Shearer of Martinsburgh, Virginia |
Important
New Evidence on a Southern Cabinetmaker
|
|
|
|
Historical
research is the process of forming tentative theories to fit
the available facts and then revising them as new bits of
information come along. This process is taking place once
again as a previously unknown example of the work of Virginia
cabinetmaker John Shearer comes up for auction on May 18th
at Ken Farmer's gallery in Radford, VA.
In recent years, an increasing amount of collector interest
as focused on readily identifiable pieces from important regional
workshops. The attention and prices garnered by works from
the Dunlaps of New Hampshire are a manifestation of this trend.
Add to this an energized research campaign in the Southeast
to document examples made by Southern cabinetmakers, spearheaded
by the efforts of the Museum of Early Southern Decorative
Arts in North Carolina and Colonial Williamsburg in Virginia.
Both these factors have contributed to heightened market appreciation
for the well-documented works of John Shearer, a cabinetmaker
who flourished in the early 19th century in Martinsburgh,
then part of Frederick County, Va., (now Martinsburg W.Va.).
A walnut chest of drawers signed by Shearer sold for $63,000
at a 1994 Skinner's Americana auction, well beyond its estimate
of $8000 - $12,000.
|
|
|
|
Shearer has
everything you could wish for in a regional furniture maker. His
high-style case pieces are well executed and idiosyncratic enough
to be easily recognizable. Williamsburg curator Jonathan Prown,
who with Ron Hurst is preparing a new book on Southern Furniture;
the Colonial Williamsburg Collection, 1680-1830, explains: "We
have to be careful not to judge Shearer by eastern urban standards,
because he was working in a different region, so his whole stylistic
and structural vocabulary was guided by a different set of rules
than in a place like London, New York or even Norfolk, Va. He was
clearly a pretty flamboyant character, but I object to
characterizations of him as being rather bizarre. You have to keep
in mind the context he is working in: he's on the frontier. He's out
there in the valley of Virginia where there were all sorts of people
and influences."
Some of this flamboyance can be deduced from the evidence Shearer
abundantly provided on his own pieces. One of his masterpieces, a
desk and bookcase in the MESDA collection, is signed no less than 20
times. The same piece of furniture also yields the date he made each
part - 1801 for the desk, 1806 for the bookcase - and the fact that
it was executed at Martinsburgh. Furthermore, he supplies several
biographical tidbits, which are repeated on other Shearer pieces:
the statement that he came from Edinburgh in 1775; and, through the
sentiment "God Save the King," that he was a confirmed
Tory sympathizer long after the Revolutions. Why he came to this
continent in those turbulent years and why he remained after the
Colonists' victory over the Crown are intriguing questions.
Southern furniture expert John Bivins, who co-authored MESDA"s
catalogue The Regional Arts of the Early South with Forsyth
Alexander, emphasizes the Scottish influence in Shearer's work:
"It seems evident that the cabinetmaker was trained in Scotland
because of the great number of Scottish stylistic details he uses,
which are really not disseminated around the lower valley in
Virginia. If you compare it with Edinburgh work, Shearer's furniture
is loaded with and eclectic blend of Baroque, Rococo, and
Neoclassical elements with a heavy emphasis on architectural detail,
which you also see on Scottish tall case clocks."
Given the hard facts Shearer placed on his own pieces and the stylistic
evidence, this Southern cabinetmaker might seem an easy biographical
subject. But previous efforts to firmly identify him with a documented
local resident of Martinsburgh are now in jeopardy. The classic
work on the artisan is a May 1979 article by John J. Snyder Jr.,
"John Shearer, Joiner of Martinsburgh" in volume V of the Journal
of Early Southern Decorative Arts. Snyder discussed the seven examples
of his work known at that time and connected the maker with a John
Shearer born in 1765 who filed a will in Washington County, Md.,
in early 1810 and died shortly thereafter. This John Shearer's family
were Scots immigrants and many facts are known about relatives,
marriages, and children, but there is no mention of his trade or
listing of any cabinetmaking tools in the will.
This identification, further more, presents two problems at either
end of Shearer's life. Snyder assumed that, since the boy John would
have come from Scotland at the age of 10 (relying on the Shearer's
own furniture inscriptions that he came from Edinburgh in 1775), he
must have trained under a local cabinetmaker in Virginia. Even if
that master was himself Scots, questions can be raised about whether
this training would account for Shearer's unusual style, or should
researchers look for another Shearer who was fully trained before
he came from Scotland? There seems to be no body of similar work in
the Martinsburgh area to suggest a regional school of Scottish influenced
cabinetmakers.
A greater problem has arisen from the recent emergence of the slant
front desk illustrated, which will soon be auctioned by Ken Farmer.
The walnut desk, which came out of a Midwestern private collection,
is sighed 11 times, has a miniature-inlaid bust resembling King
George III, and mentions the name of the patron. Alfred Belt, who
ordered the piece, another fact Shearer often included in this inscriptions.
Within a secret compartment, the desk also contained a document
written by Shearer, which refers to Belt. As far as stylistic considerations
are concerned, Bivens, who has examined the piece, says: "It falls
right in the mainstream of Shearer's work; it has all the bells
and whistles you would expect." The dates written on this desk,
however, are 1816 and 1817, long after the John Shearer identified
by Snyder is supposed to have died.
As Jonathan Prown points out, "When you get into the records, there
are a whole heck of a lot of John Shearer's in that area. It may
be that we have not pinned down the right person." All this attention
now directed on Shearer's work by the auction in Radford - the lot's
estimate is a healthy $75,000-$150,000 - should lead to more research
on a new identification which would accommodate a lifespan extending
to 1817. Another John Shearer, perhaps even a relative of the 1765-1810
candidate found by Snyder, may be discovered along with firm records
of his trade. Known pieces now number around two dozen and other
examples from the earlier and later stages of Shearer's career may
yet turn up. History may lie in the past, but our complete knowledge
of history always belongs to the future.
This
article was taken from the May 1996 issue of Antique Review
|
| |
| Onsite
Auction |
| A
Tale of Three Fireboards
|
|
|
|
On June 6, 1992 Ken
Farmer Auctions sold three fireboards at an on the premises sale in
Southwest Virginia. The first one with a folky landscape was bought by R.E.
Crawford for $25,000. The second one, ripped down the center, but with a
lion in the foreground was bought by dealer Dan Twigg, representing a
Pennsylvania client. The third fireboard went to a Roanoke, Virginia
dealer, Bob Beard and after restoration it was later re-sold to a Virginia
collector for the purchase price plus the cost of restoration, a total of
less than $3,000. In a telephone interview Mr. Beard stated that, “the
serious collectors for this type of merchandise are not plentiful and
nothing excites buyers more than a sale at the old homeplace continuously
occupied for generations.” (See the original story in MAD, September
1992, page 6-A)
|
|
|
|
One down, two to go. It’s here that the story gets interesting
Crawford sold the first fireboard to Dr. Henry Deyerle who had it
restored and put in a custom frame. According to Dr. Deyerle's
estate records, he had invested close to $35,000 in the piece. Then
in May of 1995, Sotheby’s held a sale of the Deyerle collection in
Charlottesville. Ken and Jane Farmer purchased the fireboard; lot
345, for $6,900 ($6,000 plus 15% buyers premium) and it is still in
their collection.
At Farmer’s most recent catalogue sale (May 20, 2000) the lion
fireboard was passed at $6,000. According to Farmer, the consignor,
a Virginia collector, had traded a cupboard to the original
Pennsylvania purchaser in exchange for the fireboard. The trade
reportedly represented that each party valued their items at around
$30,000. The Virginia collector currently is planning to donate the
lion fireboard to a museum. Some dealers and collectors stated that
the price dropped so drastically on both fireboards due to their
large size and painted border rather than the overall image on the
surface.
So what can we as collectors, dealers and auctioneers all learn from
this tale? First, the results from on-the-premises sales are not
always indicative of market value. Bidders get excited and emotions
run high. Sit on your wallet and not your heart the next time you
attend a sale at Grandma’s house. We all get excited at the
prospect of buying a bargain and therein lies the roots of all
competitive bidding situations. Farmer said that he had several
potential buyers for the lion fireboard in the $8,000 to $12,000
range but a $20,000 to $30,000 estimate doused any potential buying
fever. The firm is negotiating privately to secure a sale. Therein
lies the second lesson. At catalogue auctions don’t allow a low
estimate to create overconfidence in your bidding and always be
prepared to make offers on highly estimated and passed objects after
the sale.
So there you have it, 3 fireboards and prices that look like the
stock market index graph.
|
|
|
|